Dogs     |     Dog Training     |     Cats      |     Horses     |     Small Pets

Should you use


No Bark Collars?

Help Homeless Pets

with a Gift

of One Dollar

Some Advice on Citronella No Bark Collars
Adam G. Katz

Dear Adam:
I have a client who has just adopted a dog. The dog is adjusting
to its new apt., but is barking a bit when the owner leaves. A
friend of hers has lent a citronella collar for her to try.

My question is: Is there any health concerns with using the
collar in terms of the spray getting in the eyes or lungs?
I would love to hear about peoples experiences with the collars
whether they are negative or positive.

Thank you in advance!!

Dear RD:

They have a tendency to jam up. Not to mention run out of spray.
And-- although it probably won't kill the dog-- who knows what
spraying that stuff in their eyes and nose will do over a
long-term period of time.

Ideally, the dog would only need to be sprayed once or twice and
then he’d learn to never bark while wearing the collar. But
everyone I know seems to go through the refill spray bottles like
a worm eats through a discarded bologna sandwich. And this would
suggest that the correction from the spray is only motivational
enough to get the dog to cease the current exhibition of the
behavior, but is not motivational enough to make him remember to
not do it later.

I recommend the Tri-Tronics Bark Limiter. It's a quality product
(it gives the dog a mild shock when he barks) and it works very
well. Try a web search on

Good luck,

P.S. If you've already got the Citronella collar... go ahead and
try it and see if it works for you. It's not going to kill the
dog overnight. ;-) And you may just get lucky and find that one
or two sprays will be all that you need to curb the behavior… if
your dog has a fairly soft temperament to begin with.

To read more of my dog training ramblings, read about my book
(click below):
Secrets of a Professional Dog Trainer!

Awesome Dog Lover Gifts for all Breeds

Custom Search

Blossom is a good dog and doesn't need a citronella
no bark collar. Isn't Blossom such a wonderful doggie.

Cuddly Soft Stuffed Plush Dogs

Cheerful Dog Calendars